« AnteriorContinua »
Hammersmith Protestant Discussion;
AN AUTHENTICATED REPORT
THE CONTROVERSIAL DISCUSSION
REV. JOHN CUMMING, D.D.
OF THE SCOTTISH NATIONAL CHURCH, CROWN COURT, COVENT GARDEN,
DANIEL FRENCH, ESQ.
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN PROTESTANTISM AND POPERY;
HELD AT HAMMERSMITH,
DURING THE MONTHS OF APRIL AND MAY, MDCCCXXXIX.
FROM THE SHORT-HAND NOTES OF
CHARLES MAYBURY ARCHER, ESQ.
New Edition, with a copious Inder.
VIRTUE, HALL, & VIRTUE, 25, PATERNOSTER ROW.
THIS Edition is given verbatim from the Reporter's notes; improvements, both in expression and in reasoning, might, I am conscious, have been introduced into my portion of the work; but such a course would have been inconsistent with my desire to retain this Volume as a strict report of the Speeches as delivered. I have been deterred from altering Mr. French's portion by the fear of criticism, and the probable imputation of an unworthy motive. It should be remembered, that the Speeches were strictly extemporaneous.
I have read the sheets as they passed through the press, and can therefore attest the faithfuluess and accuracy of this reprint.
London, April, 1848.
JOHN CUMMING, D.D.
THIS celebrated Discussion has excited the greatest interest both among Roman Catholics and Protestants-one proof of which is the rapid sale of upwards of 2,000 copies, though published at 14s. each, and the constant demand for a New Edition.
There were selected for discussion five great subjects; there were two Chairmen at each Meeting, GEO. FINCH, Esq. M.P on the Protestant side, and C. WELD, Esq., and subsequently J. KENDALL, Esq., on the Roman Catholic side. The audiences -half Protestant and half Roman Catholic-were admitted by tickets. The Discussion lasted eleven nights. The speeches were taken down verbatim by an able reporter, and are presented in this edition precisely as delivered. It is universally allowed to be the most masterly discussion of the whole subject in modern times. Mr. FRENCH displayed greater learning and acuteness than any controversialist on the same side, for a century and upwards; but nothing can be more powerful and complete than the replies of his Reverend opponent,